How They Met: How Jim Cuddy wooed Rena Polley

Before there was Blue Rodeo, there was a love story that started at Queen's University


Published:

Jim and Rena met while they were students at Queen's University

Hot off his latest album release, Constellation, Jim Cuddy will be playing a Valentine’s Day show tonight at Massey Hall. With love in the air, we chatted with him and his wife Rena Polley about how they met and fell in love. 

How they met 
Rena: We met in our final year at Queen’s University. I knew who Jim was, but had never met him. My roommate kept trying to set me up with friends, and one day she invited me to her boyfriend’s place to watch him and Jim practice. I sat there feeling out of place and awkward. Then I saw Jim about a week later on the running track and said ‘Hi’ to him. 
Jim: I do remember Rena coming to the house where I was writing songs with a friend, but I wasn’t aware it was a set-up. My memory is seeing Rena running on the Queen’s indoor track and being so smitten by her smile. I waited for her to come out of the change room afterwards, but I missed her. So I found out where she lived, called her and asked her to go to breakfast with me the next morning.  

The first date 
R: It was the first Saturday of reading week. We had breakfast at Morrison’s in Kingston. We were talking for so long I missed my train and had to catch the next one. We earnestly talked about everything including the existence of God. I think we both found it a bit exhausting. Even though it was fun, it wasn’t the most personal date. 
J: Then a few months later Rena asked me to her grad formal and I showed up at her house in an oil oil-stained blue tux hoping to make her laugh, but she totally took it in stride. I changed into normal clothes and we had a great evening.  

The courtship
R: We really were courting the following summer back in Toronto. Jim would always call me at the last minute to join him for a late dinner. I remember eating two dinners a night for most of the summer.  

The proposal 
R: Jim and I had been together for about six years and were living in New York. I was studying acting and he had a band. We knew our days in New York were coming to an end. 
J: We were walking down to our apartment in Little Italy in New York City together and talking about going back to Toronto. I think Rena said, “Maybe we should get married,” and I got down on my knee on the broken glass strewn street and proposed. She said yes. 

The wedding 
R: We were married in Toronto in 1984. We spent our wedding night at the Windsor Arms Hotel where we had to pay cash because we didn’t own a credit card. We had just moved back from New York the week before and were broke, so Greg offered us his parent’s cottage for three days. The day after we arrived the rest of the band joined us.  

The kids
Devin, our oldest is 31, Emma is 29 and Sam is 26. 

The home
R: We have lived in Riverdale for over 30 years. When we first moved to the east end, I wept because I was convinced no one would cross the Danforth bridge to visit us. 

Secret of success
J: We both have full creative lives, which we do our best to weave into our family life as seamlessly as possible. Rena has always been really insistent on time together apart from family and work and that has been invaluable. Lastly and very importantly, we make each other laugh. 

Life after retirement 
J: Rena and I have been practicing our retirement for years. We love travel, we love time with our kids wherever and whenever, and we both love our work. Not sure how much will change. 

Missed the Massey Hall concert? You can also catch Rena Polley in A Midsummer Night's Dream at the Citadel from Feb. 22 to Mar. 11. 

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Nikki Gill is the managing editor at Post City Magazines. When she's away from her desk, you can either find her sipping on delicious teas or trotting the globe. Follow her adventures on Twitter @nikkjit.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

The great indoors

The great indoors

Posted 2 days ago
Toronto's venerable Cowboy Junkies hit Massey Hall

Toronto's venerable Cowboy Junkies hit Massey Hall

The Cowboy Junkies have quietly become one of the most important bands to come out of Toronto, and more than three decades deep they continue to turn gorgeously crafted albums that speak of the times in a way that is unique. Their latest, All That Reckoning, proves the band still has a lot to say. But it took some time to get there.
Posted 4 days ago
The biggest art bash in Toronto turns 20

The biggest art bash in Toronto turns 20

Posted 4 days ago
Confessions of a Lawrence Park shopping expert

Confessions of a Lawrence Park shopping expert

Posted 6 days ago
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module