Finally, a roadmap for policing

Report could moderate police budget now over $1 billion a year


Published:

The Honourable Michael H. Tulloch is a judge of the Court of Appeal for Ontario

Rick Madonik/Toronto Star/Getty Images

This could be the year for significant reform to Toronto policing. It could also be another missed opportunity for change. And much depends on Premier Doug Ford.

One opportunity is Justice Tulloch’s report on police activities and oversight. He recommended the province declare that carding, described as “the gathering of information for intelligence purposes where people are identified simply to create a database of individuals in the area,” be prohibited. He concluded that random street checks “have little or no verifiable benefits relating to the level of crime or arrests.”

He said officers need to be better trained so they can articulate why they are gathering information and that officers are not sufficiently trained to know when to they have a legal basis for stopping people.

He recommends anti-bias training and a Code of Practice for training. He recommends significant public education campaigns by police. 

His report also addresses the thorny question of police culture, noting that it “is a powerful force that can have a strong impact on all officers … compelling them to adopt the prevailing hierarchical norms of the organization.” He demands that Toronto Police Service develops diversity and inclusion strategies. 

These are wise and powerful recommendations. The stumbling block is Premier Ford. To show its immediate distain for Tulloch’s report, the government responded to the report late on New Year’s Eve, four days before the Tulloch report had become public. Sylvia Jones, the minister of community safety, said the report would “inform” her work — a weak response at best.

Meanwhile, Ford signalled his desire to be in personal control of policing matters by advocating his friend Ron Taverner be head of the Ontario Provincial Police. 

The second opportunity for change comes from the Ontario Human Rights Commission’s (OHRC) report A Collective Impact. The first paragraphs paint a dire picture in Toronto:

“Between 2013 and 2017, a Black person in Toronto was nearly 20 times more likely than a White person to be involved in a fatal shooting by the Toronto Police Service."

“Between 2013 and 2017, a Black person in Toronto was nearly 20 times more likely than a White person to be involved in a fatal shooting by the Toronto Police Service. Despite making up only 8.8% of Toronto’s population, data shows that Black people were over-represented in use of force cases (28.8%), shootings (36%), deadly encounters (61.5%) and fatal shootings (70%).”

It also stated that the “SIU Director’s reports reveal a lack of legal basis for police stopping or detaining Black civilians in the first place; inappropriate or unjustified searches during encounters; and unnecessary charges or arrests.”

The black community has been pointing this out for years, but the OHRC provides added weight and substance to the complaints. 

It seems unlikely the Police Services Board can make the changes needed without provincial support. Worse, the city council appointees to the board are hardly the people to push for change. One is councillor Michael Ford, Doug Ford’s nephew; another is councillor Frances Nunziata, not a voice for police change. Mayor John Tory, serving on the board for four years, has shown little interest in better policing. 

Will the recommendations run into a Conservative party wall?

The third opportunity is with new shift schedules. The current schedule sees as many primary response officers working at 4 a.m. as at 7 p.m, with officers together accumulating 28 total hours of work in a 24-hour period. A waste of police resources and public money.

In one division in Scarborough the shift schedule has been changed so that more officers are working less during the quiet times, and more when the demand for services is higher. The promise is that similar shift schedules will be introduced in all divisions. This should help moderate continual increases in police expenditures — now well over $1 billion a year.   

These are three opportunities for positive change, but our police service and its masters may not be up to the challenge.

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Post City Magazines’ columnist John Sewell is a former mayor of Toronto and the author of a number of urban planning books, including The Shape of the Suburbs.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

Jann Arden on her new TV show

Jann Arden on her new TV show

The music legend plays her fictional self in a new CTV comedy series that premieres March 20. With a new sitcom and two Juno Award nominations, things are looking up for the Canadian icon
Posted 6 days ago
Laneway suite applications rolling into Toronto

Laneway suite applications rolling into Toronto

City looks to expand program across city as homeowners eager to add units
Posted 6 days ago
University of Toronto reveals new plan for historic McLaughlin Planetarium

University of Toronto reveals new plan for historic McLaughlin Planetarium

From Laser Floyd rock shows to a nine-storey build with a recital hall
Posted 1 week ago
Is Toronto’s dating scene inherently racist?

Is Toronto’s dating scene inherently racist?

How partner preferences have become a veil for discrimination, both online and off
Posted 1 week ago
Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module