Eat this Minute: Chicago-style pizza from Double D’s

They’re all about the deep-dish


Published:

Mike Yaworski wasn’t expecting this. But ever since opening Double D’s in early 2017, Yaworski’s Chicago-style deep-dish pizza has been the hot ticket item in the city, with oh-so-eager locals breathing down his neck to get a piece of the pie. After all, this is the first time Torontonians have been able to get their paws on it without heading south of the border.  

The back story
Yaworski has been in the resto biz for 25 years, owning various bars and eateries across T.O. The restaurateur was keen to run a tiny little space with the goal of supporting his family. Yaworski chose Gerrard East due to its slightly out of the way location and relaxed vibe. 

A longtime fan of Chicago’s deep-dish pizza, Yaworski decided to open a shop devoted to the famed American food. A road trip was in order, so he grabbed his executive chef  Walt Medeiros, and they hoofed it down to the Windy City. A strict schedule saw them eat through 100 pizzas over 10 days. “We OD’d on pizza!” Yaworski exclaims.   

But despite all the heavy research, getting any clues about how the pizzas were made was easier said than done. Lips were tightly sealed. 

“It’s really secret,” Yaworski notes. “No one will tell you how to make the crust — no one will tell you anything!” 

Keepin’ it Chi-Town 
The key to deep-dish is the cheese, the tomato sauce and the crust. (“It has to have the Chicago stretch,” Yaworski says of the cheese. “It can’t be like gum.”) After much experimentation, the team mastered pizza that is on par with Chicago’s pies. And in true form, they remain mum on any details.

“They’re all Chicago authentic deep-dish pizza,” Yaworski says of Double D’s three pre-set menu offerings. “We picked the best.”  (Option B is to build your own pizza from their list of toppings.) Their Jalapeño Blue number is his personal fave and a flavour combo that was discovered on the last day in Chi-town. 

Available in sizes ranging from personal (eat-in only) to large, the ’za pairs blue cheese and the secret cheese mix with Italian sausage, shards of bacon and a generous portion of jalapenos. Spoonfuls of tomato sauce are smoothed on top of the goods. Do remember: a knife and fork are required for plowing through the pie’s two inches. Not to mention a post-pie nap. 

Double D’s, 1020 Gerrard St. E., 416-727-5411

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Karolyne Ellacott is senior editor at Post City Magazines. She can oft be spotted at Toronto’s most nostalgic diners wearing glittery heels and pink faux fur. Follow all of her eclectic writing interests on Twitter @kellacott and Instagram @itismekar.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

How the Food Dudes put their multi-faceted stamp on Toronto’s dining scene

How the Food Dudes put their multi-faceted stamp on Toronto’s dining scene

Adrian Niman and Brent McClenahan are the official co-owners of the Food Dudes, overseeing two acclaimed restaurants — Rasa and Omaw — two grab-and-go Pantry eateries and two food trucks. Oh, and they cater over 1,500 events a year.
Posted 2 days ago
Eat This Minute: T.O.’s newest New York City import has tongues wagging

Eat This Minute: T.O.’s newest New York City import has tongues wagging

Posted 3 days ago
First Look: Adamson adds Conspiracy Pizza next door to their BBQ operation

First Look: Adamson adds Conspiracy Pizza next door to their BBQ operation

Midtown’s newest pizza joint is now in its soft opening phase and doling out 18-inch pizzas ranging from $20 for a plain old cheese pizza to $28 for the brisket pizza. The style of pizza served at Conspiracy is a “New York-Italian hybrid,” says their pizzaiolo, Dan Rios.
Posted 4 days ago
At the Bar: One-two milk punch from Good Fortune

At the Bar: One-two milk punch from Good Fortune

Craft cocktail bar Good Fortune has us fooled. Clarified punch is a super old-timey way of crafting cocktails, with the best-known recipe reaching back to 1711.
Posted 5 days ago
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module