Arthur’s Restaurant emulates New York's fine dining with a dash of nostalgia

The latest venture by Chase Hospitality Group now open at Yonge and St. Clair


Published:

Shrimp & avocado ($16.95) IMAGE: MADDIE LEE

Arthur’s Restaurant brings some mid-century Manhattan flair to Yonge and St. Clair. It offers updated takes on classic American dishes for lunch and dinner, plus a weekend brunch stacked with classic Jewish brunch items and a cosy bar and lounge area in the back.

Arthur’s is the latest venture from the Chase Hospitality Group, well-known for downtown spots like The Chase, Planta and Kasa Moto. They conceived the restaurant with the local residents in mind.

“We wanted to bring a little bit of the downtown lifestyle up to Yonge and St. Clair,” Chase Hospitality Group president Steven Salm explains, “and the concept is reminiscent of a time when a lot of this community was growing up and starting their professional lives.”

The front dining room is elegantly appointed in true old-school style (think champagne ice buckets dotted throughout the room), with a spectacular ceiling centerpiece made to resemble the cut-crystal base of a drinking glass. For a more casual vibe, the back-room bar has leather-upholstered booths, sports games on the TV and Motown on the stereo.

But the most notable of the nostalgic decor is the collection of vintage ephemera — postcards, prints, school report cards — that hang in frames through the hallway and the bar area. These belong to the eponymous Arthur, Salm’s late father, a Holocaust survivor who immigrated to New York during the war. As Salm recalls, “Our most amazing, cherished moments as a family were over food.”


Endive & grapefruit ($15.05)

 

So although the menu aims to stick to classic New York fare — with a little Italian and a little French — its real source of inspiration is the taste memories of Salm and chef Tyler Shedden, a fellow American expat. The resulting dishes aren’t recreations but tributes, with '80s staples like endive and avocado salad ($15.05) updated for modern palates. 


Tuna tartare ($22.95)

 

And unlike the butter and meat-rich meals one imagines the wolves of Wall Street tossing back, dinner at Arthur’s goes down surprisingly lightly, and includes an array of herbivore-friendly options. Even a plate-sized veal chop milanese ($30.95) is given a lift with radicchio leaves and herb-covered cherry tomatoes.


Veal chop ($30.95)

 

Indulgence has been reserved for dessert. Baba au rhum (one of Shedden’s all-time favourites) leans heavy on the rum, serving up a spongy cake topped with pineapple chunks and lime chantilly cream ($13.95). And, of course, there’s a New York-style caramel cheesecake, sprinkled with freeze-dried passionfruit for a tart contrast ($13.95).


New York cheesecake ($13.95)

 

The drinks menu is a history lesson in classic cocktails, featuring martinis and Manhattans alongside Prohibition-era recipes like the Clover Club ($17). They’ll be able to be enjoyed from the 60-seater rooftop terrace that opens later this year, overlooking the city from a comfortable midtown view.


North Shore ($19)

 

Arthur's Restaurant, 12 St Clair Ave. E., 647-348-7000

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Follow us on Twitter @PostCity for more on what to eat, where to shop and what to do in Toronto.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

Inside Maison Selby, a new French bistro in one of Toronto’s historic homes

Inside Maison Selby, a new French bistro in one of Toronto’s historic homes

The latest outpost from Oliver and Bonacini now open at Bloor and Sherbourne
Posted 1 week ago
The Good Son brings its eclectic style to North York

The Good Son brings its eclectic style to North York

The Queen Street restaurant's second location now open in the Shops at Don Mills
Posted 4 weeks ago
The Annex Food Hall is Toronto's new casual hangout with fast eats

The Annex Food Hall is Toronto's new casual hangout with fast eats

Low-key space brings together a diverse group of vendors from across the city
Posted 1 month ago
Toronto shines its culinary spotlight on Peruvian fare

Toronto shines its culinary spotlight on Peruvian fare

Chef Elias Salazar proves this classic cuisine is more than just ceviches and steaks
Posted 1 month ago
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module