The Crazy Tomato, a new Italian restaurant that’s taken over the old Kitty Oshea Irish Alehouse at St. Clair and O’Connor, owners Michael Ciciarelli and Nunzio Mele are cousins who always knew of each other, but hadn’t had the chance to get to know each other until recently.">

First Look: The Crazy Tomato, a traditional Italian trattoria in East York


Published:

The thing with extended family is, you always know of them but you don’t always know them. At The Crazy Tomato, a new Italian restaurant that’s taken over the old Kitty Oshea Irish Alehouse at St. Clair and O’Connor, owners Michael Ciciarelli and Nunzio Mele are cousins who always knew of each other, but hadn’t had the chance to get to know each other until recently.

Mele started a plumbing business at 21, with a backburner goal of one day opening a restaurant. Business boomed, and 20 years, a marriage and two kids later, he was feeling antsy. The time for a restaurant was either now or never.

Enter Ciciarelli. At a family function, Mele found his cousin, 20 years his junior, all grown up, and a professional chef to boot. He learned that Ciciarelli had dreamed of opening a restaurant since he was seven years old. The two connected, and decided to go into business. The Crazy Tomato was born.


Seafood linguine, $19

The family connection fits with the theme of the restaurant.

“We are a very family, homey-style, trattoria-based restaurant,” says Ciciarelli, who has worked at restaurants such as Oro and Carisma.

The cousins built and designed the restaurant on their own, dedicating four months to the project. Mele’s background in construction helped.

The result is a comfortable and airy restaurant, with a wood-burning stove in the back and an impressive wooden harvest table at the centre to accommodate large groups.

“We wanted to have a nice family table in the middle of our dining area. It’s just a different feeling sitting around a harvest table as opposed to putting tables together,” Mele says.

Popular dishes include the seafood linguine ($19), which is topped with white wine tomato sauce. The linguine is made in-house, along with other pastas such as gnocchi and pappardelle. It comes with a massive helping of shrimps, scallops and mussels.

The Crazy Porchetta ($13, pictured below) is the restaurant’s deconstructed take on a traditional porchetta, with pork tenderloin, pancetta and sides of mashed potato, carrots, peppers and seasonal vegetables.

“We built the place ourselves,” Mele says. “It’s a passion we’re delivering on a daily basis.”

The Crazy Tomato, 2714 St. Clair Avenue E., 416-755-2020

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Follow us on Twitter @PostCity for more on what to eat, where to shop and what to do in Toronto.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

How the Food Dudes put their multi-faceted stamp on Toronto’s dining scene

How the Food Dudes put their multi-faceted stamp on Toronto’s dining scene

Adrian Niman and Brent McClenahan are the official co-owners of the Food Dudes, overseeing two acclaimed restaurants — Rasa and Omaw — two grab-and-go Pantry eateries and two food trucks. Oh, and they cater over 1,500 events a year.
Posted 6 days ago
Eat This Minute: T.O.’s newest New York City import has tongues wagging

Eat This Minute: T.O.’s newest New York City import has tongues wagging

Posted 7 days ago
First Look: Adamson adds Conspiracy Pizza next door to their BBQ operation

First Look: Adamson adds Conspiracy Pizza next door to their BBQ operation

Midtown’s newest pizza joint is now in its soft opening phase and doling out 18-inch pizzas ranging from $20 for a plain old cheese pizza to $28 for the brisket pizza. The style of pizza served at Conspiracy is a “New York-Italian hybrid,” says their pizzaiolo, Dan Rios.
Posted 1 week ago
At the Bar: One-two milk punch from Good Fortune

At the Bar: One-two milk punch from Good Fortune

Craft cocktail bar Good Fortune has us fooled. Clarified punch is a super old-timey way of crafting cocktails, with the best-known recipe reaching back to 1711.
Posted 1 week ago
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module