Mark Breslin reviews all five Grammy-nominated Comedy Albums

Every nominee in the category came from a Netflix special this year


Jerry Seinfeld's Netflix special, Life Before Seinfeld, is nominated for a Best Comedy Album at the 2018 Grammy's

I remember back in the day when people would listen to Robert Klein, Woody Allen or my own favourite, Steve Martin’s Let’s Get Small, for an entire hour in a rec room surrounded by friends. Comedy and chill, I think we called it.

Comedy albums have had their ups and downs, and lately the tide has turned again as Netflix has become the primary distributor of comedy material. 

At this year’s Grammy Awards, all five nominees in the Best Comedy Album category are from Netflix specials. But let’s get to the albums themselves.

Life Before Seinfeld, Jerry Seinfeld
This is a wonderful curiosity. He taped it at the Comic Strip, which is where he started out in the ’70s, and had the club redecorated to look like it did in 1978. There’s a theme here, and it’s what Jerry Seinfeld’s life was like before he was famous. Lots of great material about growing up in Long Island, being a teenager at the time and a lot of stuff that will make you nostalgic if not hysterical.

A Speck of Dust, Sarah Silverman
I was sceptical of this  entry. Although I’m a huge fan of hers, I thought she never matched the quality of her first outing. But I was nicely surprised by this recording. Mining her usual naughty Jewish girl character, Silverman takes us in some weird and absurd directions. She starts off a bit about cats, and you think it’s a safe and hacky piece until she twists it into a chunk about crucifying animals, which only the lightness of her persona rescues from being a repellent bit. 

Cinco, by Jim Gaffigan
If you like Jim Gaffigan, the amiable Midwestern family man, you’re going to like him here on his fifth album. But he might as well have called the album More of the Same. Same riffs about being fat, being a slacker father, eating, food, napping, travel. There’s nothing groundbreaking here. But his off-the-cuff rhythms are infectious, and his comedy goes down real easy.

What Now?, by Kevin Hart
I do not get the Kevin Hart phenomenon. The bombast and arrogance sink his set with a self-importance that’s undeserved. His riffs, which start with a 20-minute time waster on animals attacking humans, feel forced. He shouts every line, indicates every thought, and punctuates his jokes with a wail, which I thought had been retired around the time of Chris Tucker. 

The Age of Spin and Deep in the Heart of Texas, by Dave Chappelle
Finally, there’s Dave Chappelle, who came out of retirement to release not one, but two recorded specials, which make no mistake in announcing his return. The Age of Spin might be criticized for being softball comedy. But it’s like seeing an old friend for the first time in years. He ends with a bit on Bill Cosby that ties into a throwaway joke earlier in the set that shows his brilliance.

Deep in the Heart of Texas, on the other hand, reveals the Chappelle we expect: obsessed with race, a bit foul-mouthed, but with his signature sly attitude. If you took the best parts of each album, it would easily be the recording of the year.

I don’t know who’ll win, but I’m excited to see that our own Junos have finally reinstituted the comedy category for 2018. The nominees are yet to be announced.

The 60th Annual Grammy Awards will be broadcast Sunday, January 28 at 7.30 pm ET on CBS.


Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Post City Magazines’ humour columnist, Mark Breslin, is the founder of Yuk Yuk’s comedy clubs and the author of several books, including Control Freaked.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

Museum of Contemporary Art to transform Toronto

Museum of Contemporary Art to transform Toronto

Sterling Road beckons with groundbreaking art gallery and culinary destinations
Posted 3 hours ago
Richmond Hill to ban cannabis retail despite legalization?

Richmond Hill to ban cannabis retail despite legalization?

The province will provide $40 mil to municipalities to help with the cost of regulation
Posted 2 days ago
Toronto basketball star Danilo Djuricic on playing for Harvard University

Toronto basketball star Danilo Djuricic on playing for Harvard University

St. Michael's College alumnus has already met goals on and off the court, including a gold medal with Team Canada
Posted 3 days ago
What can Toronto learn about marijuana legalization from other cities?

What can Toronto learn about marijuana legalization from other cities?

Denver is reaping serious economic rewards, Montevideo is a case of what not to do, and Vancouver is the Wild West. So, what is next for Toronto?
Posted 4 days ago
Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Comedy Shows

  • Love, Remixed

     @ Trinity-St Paul's United Church

    Early instruments, new music. For the first time in our history, The Toronto Consort presents a program of 20th- and 21st-century music written for...

Show More...
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module