Taste Test: Chef Mark McEwan picks Toronto's best ice cream

Get the scoop on the city's boldest new flavours, from black sesame to rosewater white chocolate jasmine


Published:

McEwan remembers visiting Anderson’s Frozen Custard Stand in Buffalo for ice cream as a child. “I could eat a whole pint of it,” he recalls.

Chef Mark McEwan summoned up his inner child to suss out the city’s most inspirational new flavours and coolest contemporary takes on crème glacée.

WINNER: CHOCOLATE MONKEY
MY FAVOURITE ICE CREAM​

McEwan chose this as the winner because “It’s like a banana explosion in your mouth.” He says the flavour delivers on what the name promises, and he loves the caramel ripple.
3 Macpherson Ave., $10/pint


RUNNER-UP: BLACK CHERRY CHEESECAKE
DUTCH DREAMS

“That’s definitely black cherry,” McEwan exclaims. He thinks this is an excellent ice cream, and loves that “they really captured the cherry flavour. They really deliver.”
36 Vaughan Rd., $14.85/litre


PINK LEMONADE
BANG BANG ICE CREAM

“They really nailed the flavour, so when you eat it, you know what you’re eating,” says McEwan. He says it has a nice sweetness and nice brightness from the citrus and that it “eats light for an ice cream.”
93A Ossington Ave., $10/pint


BLACK SESAME
PUT A CONE ON IT

Although McEwan loves the “really nice unusual texture” of this coconut-based ice cream, he says, “it needs to go with something. It needs a travelling companion to be really successful.”
633 Bloor St. W., $10/pint


ROSEWATER WHITE CHOCOLATE JASMINE
WONG’S ICE CREAM

“This is the most elegant of all the ice creams,” says McEwan. “I thought with rosewater it was going to punch me in the face, but it’s actually subtle and quite enjoyable,” he says.
617 Gerrard St. E., $12/pint


TORONTO POTHOLE
SUMMER’S ICE CREAM​

The almonds, marshmallows, peanuts and chocolate chunks give the ice cream a nice texture and flavour, according to McEwan. But he says it “suffers a little from overindulgence. A little less would have been more.”
101 Yorkville Ave., $11.50/pint


SAFFRON PISTACHIO
BB CAFE

“I like the saffron,” says McEwan. “It’s different, but I’m just not getting the pistachio in it.” He loves that the ice cream has some contrast but wishes that the pistachio flavour stood out more.
6095 Yonge St., $7.99/medium container


CORNFLAKES
GREG’S ICE CREAM

Cornflakes, a popular classic flavour brought back for the season, is not for everyone. McEwan thinks that the flakes are soggy and “It is kind of a funny texture. There’s not a lot of taste going on there.”
750 Spadina Ave. $8.50/half litre

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Follow us on Twitter @PostCity for more on what to eat, where to shop and what to do in Toronto.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

The 10 hottest restaurants in Toronto this month

The 10 hottest restaurants in Toronto this month

Foodie power rankings for the top new spots everyone's talking about
Posted 3 days ago
Good Hombres is Toronto's newest taco joint

Good Hombres is Toronto's newest taco joint

The city's newest taqueria also doubles as a tortilla shop
Posted 4 days ago
Sassafraz gets a complete makeover in Toronto

Sassafraz gets a complete makeover in Toronto

The 20-year-old Yorkville restaurant has a new menu and a new look
Posted 6 days ago
The 10 best spots serving Thanksgiving dinner in Toronto this weekend

The 10 best spots serving Thanksgiving dinner in Toronto this weekend

A list of restaurants, gourmet grocers and butchers that will help ensure your turkey feast goes off without a hitch
Posted 1 week ago
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module