Taste Test: Who has the best cinnamon buns in town?


When the holidays roll around, McEwan’s favourite guilty pleasure is some old school Black Forest cake.

We asked chef Mark McEwan to undertake the arduous task of sampling the city’s best cinnamon buns. Which baker was crowned king? Whose buns should grace your holiday table? Read on. 

Winner: Iced perfection
Rosen’s Cinnamon Buns
“I like this one,” says McEwan after the first bite. “It’s the right size; it is very balanced; and I really like the icing on it. It also has good moisture.” 
825 College St., $4 

Runner-up: A balanced bun
Glory Hole Doughnuts
“This one takes second place,” says McEwan. “This one is very well balanced; it is a good size; and it has good moisture. It also has the right amount of icing.” 
1596 Queen St. W., $4.50

A surprising third place
“This one is super classic. It’s the right size; it has the right icing and the right look overall. You could heat it up for a couple of minutes and it would be sugar heaven,” he says. 
Fairview Mall, 1800 Sheppard Ave. E., $3.99

On the softer side
Rolling Pin
“These people know what they are doing. This one is super soft and spongy, and it tastes good,” says McEwan. “It almost feels a bit commercial, but it’s very good.” 
1970 Avenue Rd., $3.95

A cinnamon raisin twist
Sorelle and Co. 
“This one is very different. It’s kind of old school European. The sugars are cooked more, and there’s a little bit more of that really intense caramel and almost rum raisin flavour.” 
1050 Rutherford Rd., $18/loaf

The size is right
Bunner’s Bake Shop
“This one is a really good size,” says McEwan of the bun titled the Mama size. “I also like the way they’ve done the icing. My only comment would be that it’s just a little hard.” 
244 Augusta Ave., $5

An alternative option
Almond Butterfly
“This is a good option for someone who is looking for a gluten-free, dairy-free cinnamon bun,” says McEwan. “If that’s what you’re into, this is a good choice.” 
100 Harbord St., $4.50

A bun with a twist
“There’s no icing on this one, which is interesting. They have a jam that acts like a glaze on here. It’s really big, but it’s a very good product. I just miss having a little bit of icing,” he says.
268 Howland Ave., $5.50

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Nikki Gill is the managing editor at Post City Magazines. When she's away from her desk, you can either find her sipping on delicious teas or trotting the globe. Follow her adventures on Twitter @nikkjit.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

The 10 hottest restaurants in Toronto this month

The 10 hottest restaurants in Toronto this month

Foodie power rankings for the top new spots everyone's talking about
Posted 3 days ago
Good Hombres is Toronto's newest taco joint

Good Hombres is Toronto's newest taco joint

The city's newest taqueria also doubles as a tortilla shop
Posted 4 days ago
Sassafraz gets a complete makeover in Toronto

Sassafraz gets a complete makeover in Toronto

The 20-year-old Yorkville restaurant has a new menu and a new look
Posted 6 days ago
The 10 best spots serving Thanksgiving dinner in Toronto this weekend

The 10 best spots serving Thanksgiving dinner in Toronto this weekend

A list of restaurants, gourmet grocers and butchers that will help ensure your turkey feast goes off without a hitch
Posted 1 week ago
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module