First Look: Pair of friends open Brothers to offer casual and graceful dining above Bay Station


Citrus yogurt cake with sea buckthorn berries ($9)

Image: David Ort

“You’re going to eat food, that’s all I can promise,” Chris White says of the restaurant he and his good friend, Jonathan Nicolau, opened above Bay Station.

The two have been working on developing the idea for a restaurant — in the end, it needed to be "casual and graceful and nice and in the centre of the city” — almost from the time they met. Both were working on the bar side of the business; Nicolau at the Swan in its heyday and White at Terroni’s Queen West outpost. 

For Brothers, their division of labour has Nicolau run the kitchen and White behind the 16-plus-seat bar. 

“You can explain a lot with functionality,” say White of how the room is divided. “If you walk in and it’s mostly bar that’s going to answer intelligent people’s questions right there.”

Mackerel, pickled eggplant, mint ($15) (IMAGE: DAVID ORT)


The setup also allows him to tap into the operational ethos of a diner — without the clatter or grease.

He explains that the food tends away from composed, full-meals-on-a-plate in favour of meat and a vegetable complement together with sides ordered separately. Even though the menu changes constantly (something will rotate every day depending on whim and what suppliers bring in), they print a menu to help put guests at ease and to avoid making them crane to see a chalkboard or sit through a long recitation of the day’s options. 

“Critical thought plays a huge role,” White says of how Nicolau designs dishes. “Ethics, localism all the shit we should have been doing for the last forty years without talking about it” motivate choices. 

Beef carpaccio, enoki mushrooms, shallots, wheat berries ($17) (IMAGE: DAVID ORT)


Because it is one of their own favourite ways to start a meal, carpaccio, in some form or another, will almost always earn a spot on the menu. 

The simple-sounding combination of mackerel, mint and pickled eggplant has been a mainstay for their first three months of business.

Local craft beer options complement the wine on the list (IMAGE: DAVID ORT)


To emphasize the essential combination with food, they put “wine” in the name of the restaurant. The list, just as likely to change, is put together by sommelier Courtney Stebbings. She comes to Brothers after stints at Lyle’s and the famous River Cafe in London. 

When debating how to convert the space  — formerly Cafe Iris, a Chinese restaurant that also specialized in sandwiches and all-day breakfast — they leaned heavily on their own experience, advice from friends who are professional designers and Nicolau’s every-issue collection of World of Interiors back to when he was seventeen. 

Popularity from attention has stretched the capacity of the 30-seat room, but White stresses how important local regulars are to the business and, while they do take reservations, he tries to hold back a few seats for walk-ins.

Brothers Food & Wine, 1240 Bay St., 416-804-6066, Mon. to Sat. from 11 a.m. - 11 p.m.

Sweetbreads, artichoke, frisee ($18) (IMAGE: DAVID ORT)


Clams, white wine, butter ($17) (IMAGE: DAVID ORT)


Beets, garlic yogurt, bread ($13) (IMAGE: DAVID ORT)


Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

David Ort is the web editor at and the author of The Canadian Craft Beer Cookbook. Check out his site, follow him on Instagram and Twitter for more great beer and food content. Have a story idea? Get in touch at

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

Toronto malls are stepping up their food game

Toronto malls are stepping up their food game

Hemant Bhagwani is opening two new restaurants inside North York shopping centres
Posted 8 hours ago
The 10 hottest restaurants in Toronto this month

The 10 hottest restaurants in Toronto this month

Foodie power rankings for the top new spots everyone's talking about
Posted 3 days ago
Good Hombres is Toronto's newest taco joint

Good Hombres is Toronto's newest taco joint

The city's newest taqueria also doubles as a tortilla shop
Posted 4 days ago
Sassafraz gets a complete makeover in Toronto

Sassafraz gets a complete makeover in Toronto

The 20-year-old Yorkville restaurant has a new menu and a new look
Posted 6 days ago
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module