Taste Test: Father's Day Grillfest

Celebrity chef Mark McEwan and Drew Ellerby  of One restaurant joined us to ’cue up and taste the best cuts of steak from some of the city’s top butchers and glam grocers



Published:

Mark McEwan and Drew Ellerby should us how to grill the best steak.

WINNER: PUSATERI'S
Wet-aged New York strip loin

This one has the best fat flavour, says McEwan. “The fat tastes caramelized, and it has a pronounced beef flavour. Super tender, just the right cut and thickness.” “It tasted like what a steak was supposed to taste like,” says Ellerby.
2901 Bayview Ave., $26.99/lb

 

RUNNER-UP: CUMBRAE'S
New York strip loin

“Nice and tender and nicely marbled,” says McEwan. “It’s still a very good steak, just slightly less so.” Ellerby points out, “It was the right cut and thickness. The butchering on it was great.”
1589 Bayview Ave., $34.99/lb

 

OLLIFFE
Prime strip loin Angus 

McEwan and Ellerby like the steak but  agree it lacks the flavour of the top two. It was tender but cut too thinly. “It cooks faster so you can’t get a bark on the steak,” says McEwan.
1097A Yonge St., $39/lb

 

​MAGEN MEATS 
Wet-aged rib-eye
“Rib-eyes should be thick so you can caramelize the fat. A skinny rib-eye doesn’t do the cut any justice,” says Ellerby. McEwan says it was tender but average.
1118 Centre St., Unit 21, Thornhill, $65/kg

 

SUMMERHILL MARKET 
AAA New York strip loin

“It tastes grassy but also has a lot of marbling,” says McEwan. The chefs both agree that it was fine overall, but it was “a bit short on flavour.” 4
46 Summerhill Ave., $22.99/lb

 

HEALTHY BUTCHER
Wagyu tenderloin, grade 4–6

Ellerby likes how nice and tender this cut is. McEwan says, “The taste had some grassy notes at the end, which made it that much more interesting.”
298 Eglinton Ave. W., $48/lb

 

VINCE GASPARRO'S
Top sirloin
“The flavour is alright, it’s just the cut,” says Ellerby. “You need to marinate a steak like this. If you sliced it thick and made sandwiches, you could do a nice job,” says McEwan.
857 Bloor St. W., $13.99/lb

 

Edit Module

Join the conversation and have your say by commenting below. Our comment system uses a Facebook plugin. Please note that you'll have to turn off some ad-blockers in order to see the comments.

Edit Module

Follow us on Twitter @PostCity for more on what to eat, where to shop and what to do in Toronto.

Edit ModuleShow Tags

You may also like...

Alma is a delicious one-woman show

Alma is a delicious one-woman show

Chef Anna Chen, formerly of Scaramouche and Buca, draws crowds with her Bloordale bistro in Toronto
Posted 1 day ago
Toronto's non-greasy spoons reinvent a classic

Toronto's non-greasy spoons reinvent a classic

Jen Agg’s new diner Le Swan is a perfect foil to Aloette
Posted 1 day ago
Inside Bar Buca's sleek new Toronto outpost

Inside Bar Buca's sleek new Toronto outpost

There's Pugliese-style pizza aplenty at this Yonge and Eglinton restaurant
Posted 3 days ago
Storm Crow Manor is Toronto's new bar for geeks

Storm Crow Manor is Toronto's new bar for geeks

A labyrinth of rooms await inside, each with a unique theme for every fandom
Posted 6 days ago
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleEdit Module